Search on Ifri.org

About Ifri

Frequent searches

Suggestions

The Last-ditch Attempt to Build the Energy Union

|
Date de publication
|
Références
Note de l'Ifri
Image de couverture de la publication
Frontpage Energy Union
Accroche

Nearly one year after the presentation of the Energy Union project, while 2016 promises to be a critical year for its implementation, what is the status of this flagship project of the Juncker Commission?

Image principale
image_note_europe_energie_cm.jpg
Corps analyses

Analysis of each of the three dimensions of the Energy Union project – strategic, political and economic – leads to scepticism about the ability to re-establish a climate and energy policy which actually works.

Internationally, the Energy Union in its inception like in its ambitions, is marked by the return of geopolitics. It makes a welcome break from the disconnected and idealistic approach to international realities which characterised the climate and energy policy up to now. However, is it a response commensurate with the ongoing geopolitical upheavals? If the very principle of reconnecting with international realities is achieved, sound diagnosis of the upheavals at work is still missing. In particular, the re-emergence of the United States as the sole global energy power, or even the fundamental changes in the oil and gas markets with the emergence of unconventional hydrocarbons would deserve careful monitoring. The adapting and modelling of the impact of geopolitical developments on Europe is still missing.

Politically, the Juncker Commission's ambition must be welcomed for leaving major ideological debates behind and taking action, while maintaining dialogue and promoting support. The proactive approach and the renewed governance of the climate and energy policy are necessary to counterbalance the centrifugal forces at work which put the very principle of an enhanced European energy policy at risk, because who really wants the Energy Union in a Europe which combines a revival of nationalism and urgent crises, tipping the energy issue between the exclusive preserve of the Member States and an afterthought at the major European summits? Moreover, positions are becoming tense in some Member States who are even rejecting the very principle of energy transition. Finally, new irritants are occurring, such as the Nordstream 2 gas pipeline project, without the fundamental differences in the relationship with Russia having been resolved or the objectives of electricity market reform fulfilled.

The Energy Union is ambitious in its economic component, without clarifying its ability to restore confidence among investors and calmness among consumers. The carbon market reform is not convincing, while that of the electricity market will bring up the great debates between regulation and market, 20 years after the initial directives on liberalising the energy markets in Europe. Yet, while the European Union is struggling with the definition of its market model and risks getting lost in debates, still too often tainted by ideology, big data is advancing in all sectors including energy. Where is the digital revolution in the Energy Union? Who will implement it when the large European utilities are bled dry, and when the American Internet giants are in a position to choose how they will change the sector completely?

Everybody wants the Energy Union, but everyone can define it according to their interests, as it has a variable geometry. This plan will fail if it is only a war machine against Russia. What Europe needs is a pragmatic project. The European Union must find its own shale gas revolution, that is to say a policy which ensures its energy security, strengthens its economy, and which allows it to play an appropriate role against climate change, without reducing its freedom of action in the world, but rather increasing it. Otherwise, the European Energy Union will be in the world what it was at the COP 21: voiceless and paralysed.

Decoration

Available in:

Regions and themes

Share

Download the full analysis

This page contains only a summary of our work. If you would like to have access to all the information from our research on the subject, you can download the full version in PDF format.

The Last-ditch Attempt to Build the Energy Union

Decoration
Author(s)
Photo
Cécile MAISONNEUVE

Cécile MAISONNEUVE

Intitulé du poste

Ancienne conseillère, Centre énergie et climat de l'Ifri

Image principale
Climate & Energy
Center for Energy & Climate
Accroche centre

Ifri's Energy and Climate Center carries out activities and research on the geopolitical and geoeconomic issues of energy transitions such as energy security, competitiveness, control of value chains, and acceptability. Specialized in the study of European energy/climate policies as well as energy markets in Europe and around the world, its work also focuses on the energy and climate strategies of major powers such as the United States, China or India. It offers recognized expertise, enriched by international collaborations and events, particularly in Paris and Brussels.

Image principale

EU-UK Summit: The Need for a Reset

Date de publication
20 November 2026
Accroche

Since Brexit officially entered into force in 2020, the United Kingdom (UK) has worked to forge a new partnership with the European Union (EU). Serving its interests has meant getting closer to the EU in several economic sectors, without ever officially working towards EU reaccession.

Image principale

Strategic Redundancy beyond Hormuz: Alternative Oil and Gas Corridors and Türkiye’s Emerging Role

Date de publication
17 November 2026
Accroche

The central question raised by the present crisis in the Gulf and the disruption of navigation through the Strait of Hormuz is not simply how quickly and lastingly normal flows can be restored, but whether the regional energy architecture can continue to rely so heavily upon a single maritime corridor. 

Hasan Selim ÖZERTEM Ahmet Erdi ÖZTÜRK
Image principale

Mining Nationalism and Export Restrictions: The Challenges of Economic Development

Date de publication
12 November 2026
Accroche

Since the end of the 2000s and especially the 2010s, resource nationalism has been on the rise.

Thibault MICHEL Candice ROCHE Emmanuel HACHE
Image principale

Solar Radiation Management: A Climate Tool with Geopolitical Implications

Date de publication
26 October 2026
Accroche

The Paris Agreement (2015) aims to keep global warming below 2 °C, preferably 1.5 °C, above pre-industrial levels. Mitigation (reducing greenhouse gas emissions) remains the core tool for reaching net carbon neutrality  by mid-century. However, a temperature overshoot is anticipated.  The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) forecasts that the 1.5 °C threshold will be exceeded in the coming years, with warming potentially peaking between 2.2 °C and 3.6 °C this century.  Against this backdrop, three trends characterize the climate policy debate.

Xavier LANDES
Related Subjects

How can this study be cited?

Image de couverture de la publication
Frontpage Energy Union
Cécile MAISONNEUVE, « The Last-ditch Attempt to Build the Energy Union », Ifri, 7 April 2016.
Copy
Image de couverture de la publication
Frontpage Energy Union

The Last-ditch Attempt to Build the Energy Union