The Hunt for Economic Security: The Role of Navies in Deterring Threats to the Maritime Economy
The maritime domain is currently faced with a wide variety of threats, such as climate change, economic warfare, shadow fleet operations, protection of critical infrastructures, and illicit activities ranging from illegal fishing to piracy. Navies suffer from inherent limitations when deterring threats to the global maritime economy: their global presence and permanence limits their credibility in terms of deterrence, their focus usually set on immediate deterrence, implementing deterrence by punishment in and from the naval domain is difficult and costly.
This publication is the winner of the Admiral Castex 2025 prize. Admiral Castex’s prize, named after a French naval officer best known for his work as a naval theorist and his contributions to maritime strategy, aims to promote original and unique research into naval strategy.
There are several factors that could help navies mitigate those constraints:
- Increased reliance on multirole platforms for standard naval operations;
- Better burden-sharing between actors, allies and partners, navies and the civilian sector;
- Strategic integration of unmanned systems (UAVs, UUVs, USVs) to create mass.
The classic literature in naval and maritime strategy has long identified a strong relationship between the characteristics of naval forces and one of the main features of their political utility, namely protecting sea lines of communication in order to enable trade, and thus wealth. Alfred Thayer Mahan went so far as to argue that the core purpose of a navy is to enable maritime trade and economic growth. However, the modern maritime economy faces a range of threats that naval forces must confront: climate change, economic warfare, shadow fleet operations, the vulnerability of critical infrastructures, and illicit activities like piracy and illegal fishing.
In principle, the strategic practice of deterrence offers a cost-effective means to address these challenges. Yet, we argue that achieving deterrence against threats to the maritime economy is fraught with difficulties stemming from the very nature of naval power. Building on the conceptual literature on deterrence, we identify those challenges and explore how navies can effectively deter threats to the maritime economy. Ultimately, deterring threats to the maritime economy with naval platforms is difficult, but some steps can be taken to reduce the magnitude of the challenge.
Available in:
Themes and regions
ISBN / ISSN
Share
Download the full analysis
This page contains only a summary of our work. If you would like to have access to all the information from our research on the subject, you can download the full version in PDF format.
The Hunt for Economic Security: The Role of Navies in Deterring Threats to the Maritime Economy
Author(s)
Related centers and programs
Discover our other research centers and programs
Security Studies Center
Heir to a tradition dating back to the founding of Ifri, the Security Studies Center provides public and private decision-makers as well as the general public with the keys to understanding power relations and contemporary modes of conflict as well as those to come. Through its positioning at the juncture of politics and operations, the credibility of its civil-military team and the wide distribution of its publications in French and English, the Center for Security Studies constitutes in the French landscape of think tanks a unique center of research and influence on the national and international defense debate.
Defense Research Unit
The Defense Research Unit is a program that aims at stimulating the strategic debate by dealing with subjects at the junction of the “technico-operational” and the “political-strategic”. A unique structure in France, it brings together civilian researchers and “military fellows” from each of the three armies to produce work on defense policies, the capability and strategic adaptation of armies, and foresight on tomorrow's conflicts.
Find out more
Discover all our analyses
A Fragile Consensus? The Pressure on the Norm Against Nuclear Testing
Apart from North Korea, no state has conducted explosive nuclear tests in the 21st century, reflecting the emergence of a strong international norm against such testing.
The Franco-German Brigade and the Revival of European Defense
One thing has been clear since Donald Trump's return to the White House: the very existence of the European unification project is threatened. Unless it develops a sovereign defense policy to counter the war in Ukraine and the weakening of American security guarantees, the European Union will continue to see its internal cohesion and external attractiveness wane.
Taking the Pulse: Can Europeans Build Their Independent Extended Nuclear Deterrent?
Confronted with a U.S. disengagement and the Russian threat, Europeans are reconsidering their stance on nuclear deterrence. Given the capabilities of the French and British arsenals, can Europe develop an independent nuclear deterrent?
RAMSES 2024. A World to Be Remade
For its 42nd edition, RAMSES 2024 identifies three major challenges for 2024.