Industry Response to New Protectionism
In this special issue of Politique étrangère devoted to the proceedings of the conference organized by Ifri on April 10, 2019, in the Grand Amphitheater of the Sorbonne, on the occasion of its fortieth anniversary, discover the debate moderated by Thierry de Montbrial between Jean-Paul Agon and Patrick Pouyané.
Thierry de Montbrial
Is Total a French company? Is L'Oréal a French or Swiss company? In this session, we would like to see how two large international companies are affected by what geopoliticians or geoeconomists perceive as the major uncertainties for the future. Their operations are indeed geopolitical by nature.
Total's and L'Oréal's market capitalization as at April 3, 2019 is very close; L'Oréal prevails with 134.6 billion euros, ahead of Total at 132.1. When we look at turnover, it is 177 billion for Total and 27 billion for L'Oréal. As for operating profit, it is 13.6 billion euros for Total and 4.9 for L'Oréal; the net result is 11.5 for Total and 3.9 billion for L'Oréal. Cash flow is 10.3 for Total and 3.9 for L'Oréal, and investments are 10.5% for Total and 1.4% for L'Oréal. In terms of staff, Total has 104,000 and L'Oréal 86,000. How is it that the market capitalization is the same, with such different figures? How is it that Total's market capitalization is not markedly higher than L'Oréal's? Could there not be explanations related to geopolitical uncertainties behind this?
Oil and gas: specific geopolitics
Patrick Pouyanné
All of this raises the question of the future of large oil and gas companies. We are in a world where energy transition is gaining a foothold. This is why Total is implementing not only an oil and gas strategy, but also an electricity one. The question is, really: what will the future of our companies be? Of course, the framework of our thinking is geopolitical. Our largest competitors are “Anglo-Saxon”, the major global shareholders are American and British, and as always, they prefer to invest in companies in their country rather than those in a Europe, whose geopolitical future seems uncertain. Many US oil companies are just about 1.5 times larger than mine.
I would like to recall some characteristics specific to the world of energy.
It is a very capital-intensive industry. Companies like ours must develop resources in many countries that lack the financial means to do so themselves. It is a long-term industry (we invest in projects over 20 or 30 years); an industry that implements a lot of technical skills (engineering) – we have to provide a strong innovative capacity: you do not improvise as a geologist or driller... Finally, this industry affects states' national sovereignty. Our profession is to develop the natural resources of the countries we work in, and these natural resources generate significant tax revenue. Therefore, we are a key partner of the states involved. [...]
Jean-Paul Agon is Chairman and CEO of ‘L’Oréal.
Patrick Pouyanné is Chaiman and CEO of Total.
Thierry de Montbrial is Founder and Executive Chairman of Ifri.
Available in:
Themes and regions
Share
Download the full analysis
This page contains only a summary of our work. If you would like to have access to all the information from our research on the subject, you can download the full version in PDF format.
Industry Response to New Protectionism
Author(s)
Thierry de MONTBRIAL
Founder and Executive Chairman of Ifri - Member of the Institut de France (Académie des Sciences morales et politiques)
Find out more
Discover all our analyses
A New Path for Europe
The construction of the European Union is historically inseparable from the emergence, at the end of World War II, of an Atlantic world dominated by the United States. Successive enlargements and the revision of U.S. policy are undermining the concepts upon which the European Union has been built since the fall of the USSR. It is undoubtedly time to return to a path of more diverse groupings, corresponding to the levels of commitment and the interests of the states of the Old Continent.
How Technology Is Reshaping the World Order
The central role of technology in the competition between the major powers is fueling an ever-more intense rivalry. Artificial intelligence is enabling large corporations to accrue unprecedented power, with consequences for states and even for international conflict. However, states do have tools at their disposal to regulate these developments. In this international competition, Europe has a strong hand, but must be prepared to play its cards in order to create a new kind of international cooperation.
Reflections on A Darkening World
The system that emerged after the Second World War to regulate international relations is now moribund. Russia and China may have weakened it, but it seems that Donald Trump’s United States may deliver the fatal blow. The prevailing atmosphere is one of power struggles, and the rise of nationalisms is fraught with danger. The artificial intelligence revolution also needs to be factored into this equation, as it has a strong bearing on how much power different players can exert. In this respect, Europe must ensure it does not get left behind.
1936-2026: 90th Anniversary of the Journal "Politique étrangère"
Founded in 1936 and published by the French Institute of International Relations (Ifri), Politique étrangère, France’s longest-running journal of international relations, is set to publish a special issue in early June 2026. Bringing together distinguished French and international contributors, this issue aims to provide an overview of an uncertain world and its possible futures. In an unprecedented undertaking, Politique étrangère brings together a wide range of international contributions in an effort to grasp a global landscape that is at once open and fragmented, in all its diversity and dynamism. Through in-depth analyses of cross-cutting challenges, reflections on methods and structures of governance, and projections into futures feared or envisioned by creators from around the world—ranging from alternative histories to speculative thought experiments—the various approaches complement and challenge one another, opening up broad avenues for reflection.